Remembering The Great Manuel Puig, Cosmopolitan Chronicler Of The Everyday

Puig is simply a communal surname successful Spanish, pinch a Catalan etymology that intends “hill” and was pronounced arsenic “pweeg” not arsenic “puch” because, arsenic South Americans, his family utilized Castilian alternatively than Catalan pronunciation. The novelist Manuel Puig is remembered today, by group complete 40 aliases 50, chiefly because of nan Oscar-winning movie and nan Broadway philharmonic deed based connected his 4th novel, Kiss of nan Spider Woman. Born successful 1932 successful a mini municipality connected nan Argentine pampas, Manuel recovered his salvation successful writing. Growing up arsenic a homosexual successful a Catholic country, he had to unrecorded a double life, moreover pinch his family. 

Article continues aft advertisement

By nan clip I met Manuel, he was an up-and-coming prima (or “starlet” arsenic he ever preferred nan feminine). La Traición de Rita Hayworth, his first caller to beryllium published successful Spanish, had won a awesome prize successful Spain, and his 2nd caller Boquitas pintadas was a bestseller successful South America. Betrayed by Rita Hayworth began arsenic a grounded screenplay—Manuel’s driving ambition since puerility had been to make movies—and became his autobiographical first novel. It was not only radically unconventional successful its form, successful which only nan characters speak and location is apparently nary author, but besides successful its content, powerfully focused connected women, a subversive attack wrong a patriarchal civilization of machismo.

With his campy sensibility [Puig] pinpoints truthful accurately nan kitsch euphemisms, nan mundane connection of evasion.

The characters are mostly children, adolescents, and women, and nan scholar is guided only by what appears to beryllium their unexpurgated monologues aliases dialogues successful which nan speakers are not identified. There are besides diaries, a written duty for school, and a letter, and nan main characteristic is Toto (thinly disguising Puig’s ain puerility nickname, Coco), a lonely boy who becomes a keen voyeur of nan big world, truthful that he is not only 1 of nan speakers but also, for illustration nan reader, a listener. 

As a translator, I was swept distant by Puig’s perfectly nuanced, almost uncanny imitations of Argentine voices, chopped according to age, gender aliases class. As I began to construe this caller it was some breathtaking and difficult to undertake this imaginative challenge, to bring into English nan surviving spoken connection of nan original, to reproduce their earthy voice, nan measurement they speak. With his campy sensibility he pinpoints truthful accurately nan kitsch euphemisms, nan mundane connection of evasion. His books are subtle useful of creation utilizing campy comically unsubtle materials, accessible yet sophisticated; they had celebrated entreaty but were besides precocious art. 

In his galore interviews, Manuel explained nan domiciled of movies successful his childhood, telling america that “Mama would return maine to nan movies successful nan afternoons to entertain maine and herself, and I decided that reality was what was connected nan surface and that my destiny was to unrecorded mislaid successful nan mediate of nan pampas successful a bad impromptu Western.” The movies that were “reality” to him were Hollywood dreams successful nan shape of melodramas and comedies. His puerility astatine nan movies was an flight from a dreary and constricted mundane life successful a mini agrarian town. 

In Washington Heights, nan New York vicinity wherever I grew up successful nan 1950s and early 60s, erstwhile my mother and begetter took maine pinch them to nan movies connected Saturday nights arsenic they couldn’t spend a babysitter, this excursion was nan biggest dainty of nan week, arsenic it was for Toto successful Manuel’s novel. My parents seemed oblivious to nan effect nan much “mature” films mightiness person connected a child; I was astir 12 (when overseas films were still uncommon if not taboo) erstwhile they took maine to And God Created Woman. This French movie featured nan sexiest female successful nan world astatine that time, Brigitte Bardot, who appears successful nan nude and whose hubby mightiness beryllium impotent. Whether aliases not I was alert of what impotence meant, nan movie pulsated pinch perverse eroticism and I felt funny astir it but, needless to say, cipher explained anything.

In nan speech of five-year-old Toto successful Betrayed by Rita Hayworth, Manuel shows really his young avatar was disturbed by a supposedly acquisition movie shown astatine schoolhouse astir nan oversea world. As an guiltless spectator he thinks nan underwater images are “hairy” plants that look for illustration what he seems to see threatening vaginas swallowing small fish; he associates nan hairy image pinch a activity enactment he spies connected betwixt a boy and a girl, a segment I translated as, “…the boy’s hairs commencement eating her behind…and small by small eats her each up.” Sex looks very scary from this position for nan young child.

He felt isolated successful his location state not only because of its hostility to homosexuals, but because it was truthful acold from Gotham and Paris.

Through his first novel, Manuel already seemed to beryllium inviting nan scholar to understand his homosexuality, aliases to have, astatine least, compassion for his plight. I could subordinate this invitation to my ain request to understand and to judge my problematic relationships, pinch older men and past pinch cheery men, and my relation of nan seductive pinch perversion aliases taboos. I had overmuch older siblings, and successful a way, I grew up arsenic an “only” child, connected nan sidelines of nan life of older parents, conscionable arsenic Toto saw movies done his mother’s eyes. By sharing intensely his mother’s excursions to nan movie and that for her, going to nan movies was a wondrous escape, nan happiest infinitesimal of her day, for him nan world and nan movies became one, and he preferred nan movies, a amended type of reality. The movies for millions of group during difficult times were a measurement to escape, to liberate themselves from conscious worries, aliases to will oneself into a amended life. Such was nan lawsuit of my parents, a position that I adopted, for illustration Toto, earlier I was alert that it was a constituent of position alternatively than a fact.

When I met him successful 1969, Manuel was stopping connected his measurement from Paris to Buenos Aires. Manuel was an incessant traveler, not different for an Argentine and, successful those days, for a cheery man. Argentina, astatine nan bottommost of South America, is simply a state measurement disconnected course, and populated mostly pinch nan children of Europeans for whom walking is for illustration breathing, who miss nan world, nan centers of culture, truthful very acold way. Manuel ever claimed to beryllium seeking existent love, and I do judge he was. Mexico and New York would beryllium location successful exile from fascist Argentina until he moved to Brazil successful 1980, however, he perpetually traveled successful pursuit of his occupation and, arsenic he said, existent love, often astatine bookfairs, wherever he would meet pinch publishers and translators. Like astir Argentines who had nan intends to travel, he felt isolated successful his location state not only because of its hostility to homosexuals, but because it was truthful acold from Gotham and Paris, aliases 42nd Street and nan Moulin Rouge, that is, civilization. 

He was good-looking, for illustration an Italian type of Tyrone Power, my partner Emir had told me, and truthful erstwhile I saw a slight, dark-haired chap who vaguely fresh this La Dolce Vita explanation briskly participate nan revolving doorway of nan Chinese edifice successful Greenwich Village that acold nighttime successful December, I knew it had to beryllium Puig. His cervix wrapped successful a scarf up to his nose, and wearing a leather jacket, he quickly sighted Emir and came complete to our booth.

I could show from Manuel’s large mischievous eyes pinch agelong heavy eyelashes, that he was amazed upon gathering me, possibly somewhat shocked by nan property gap, having known his distinguished friend Emir (who looked his years astatine forty-eight) arsenic nan hubby of an elegant Uruguayan nine female his ain age, and present he was pinch this American woman pinch consecutive brownish hairsbreadth and bangs, who looked truthful young. Manuel took successful this opposition pinch 1 writerly glimpse arsenic nan 2 of them chatted eagerly, catching up, not having seen each different for rather immoderate time, pinch a batch of h2o nether nan span for them both. I chimed successful now and again, particularly erstwhile nan taxable was movies.

Manuel—for whom nan past awesome Hollywood movie was Sunset Boulevard, made successful 1950—found nan “new realism” of modern films to beryllium constricted and limiting. Hence, he nicknamed 4 “new Hollywood” (i.e. existent alternatively than glamorous) 1970s women stars (among them nan admirable Ellen Burstyn) nan “Four Horsewomen of nan Apocalypse.” This was not a compliment.

__________________________________

From Unfaithful: A Translator’s Memoir by Suzanne Jill Levine. Copyright © 2025. Available from Bloomsbury Academic, an imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing.